Opinion | The End of Roe, the End of Trump

For many supporters of former President Donald Trump, Friday’s decision by the Supreme Court was a long-awaited vindication.

Court Judgment 6 to 3 in Dobbs v. Jackson The Women’s Health Organization overturned the landmark 1973 abortion case Roe v. Wade. That’s a result Realizable by Mr. Trump’s three appointments to the bench – Judges Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett – and his supporters were quick to thank him to win and ridicule Never did Trumpers doubt the president.

Dobbs will be “the lasting legacy of President Donald J. Trump,” tweeted Andrew Giuliani, who died this week in the Republican primaries for governor of New York, and is the son of former Trump campaign attorney Rudy Giuliani. “For the Never Trumps: Elections matter. Here is a link to the verdict” Written Melissa Mackenzie, publisher of The American Spectator. “Give Trump the credit he deserves,” she concluded.

Conventional wisdom suggests that this praise will translate into votes for Mr. Trump for the next Republican presidential nomination. The ruling “will likely be the focus of his appeal to conservatives if/when he runs for president again in 2024,” Debate CNN’s Chris Cillizza shortly after Dobbs dropped. Mr. Trump quickly gained credit for the ruling while potential The opponents were clearly silent.

Predicting voter behavior is often a chore, and conventional wisdom can prove right. But it seems more likely that Republican voters – or at least a significant portion of them – are saying thanks and forwards from Mr. Trump.

Dobbs It feels like an epilogue to a story that began in 2015. Mr. Trump brought up the Supreme Court nominations as a means of overturning Roe. an important promise in his Campaign 2016describe it as one thing is for sure at his last presidential debate. Roe’s end will “happen automatically”, he say, he was elected and could appoint multiple judges. Now it yes happened. As Trump’s own supporters will speak: promise made, promise kept. That, and the mere fact that competition in the 2024 Republican primaries seems not only possible but possible, suggests that a political season is near..

Mr. Trump is not a man of all seasons. A substantial part of the ex-president’s appeal to his base is his destructive ability. His talk about taking on a “cheat system” and “profound state” conjures up images of a legitimate American government job. He will introduce “administrative state restructuring” and pave the way for a “new political order”, in words by Stephen Bannon, then his chief strategist. After all, destroying a swamp is destroying it.

President Trump’s view, to a core segment of his supporters, is that he functions as a ball of destruction. However, with Dobbs and Roe’s decision undone, the maximum reduction the voter desired was completed.

In the future, they may want a new candidate for a new era, someone better suited for the construction job than demolition – or, at the very least, someone with more diverse talents, less baggage. more personal and more substantial administrative records. This horse-swap opportunity could be particularly appealing to the small group of Republicans who have clearly established their support Trump as a deal to fill the Supreme Court seats and thus end Roe.

“I voted for the Supreme Court. I don’t want to vote for Trump,” said a pro-life voter named Jim George told The Washington Post in 2017. “With Trump, you just hold your nose.” Dobbs gives George and Republicans like him the opportunity to open their nostrils to more conventionally appealing scents. The same goes for any Republican whose record beyond the Supreme Court – unequal borders, unending war, very intact bureaucracy – has caught. The head looks a bit thin.

It’s too early to say who the new candidate might be, but Florida’s Republican governor, Ron DeSantis, who is increasingly speculate about like Mr. Trump’s most formidable challenger could fit the bill. (ONE recent poll shows Mr. DeSantis leading Mr. Trump as the first choice among Republican primary voters in New Hampshire, who watch Fox News between 46% and 32%, and 54% to 34% among those who see Mr. listen to conservative radio.) Republicans can shift their allegiance to Mr. . DeSantis or some other 2024 contender without jeopardizing Mr. Trump’s “lasting legacy”. Where the Supreme Court and abortion policy are concerned, they have nothing to lose by moving on and with a more competent and disciplined leader, much is likely to be gained. .

Mr. Trump’s own reaction to the ruling is illustrative here. His statement teased a coming national salvation, perhaps through his own re-election, but offered no vision for a post-Roe agenda. Maybe it’s because of Mr. Trump, always unconvincing supporters, appeared uncertain about the world he had created. Speaking Friday on Fox News, he was blunt pose that “Ultimately, this is something that will work for everyone.” But reported in The Times and Rolling StoneCiting unnamed sources close to the former president, said his first reaction to Dobbs’ decision was to worry about how it would affect his standing with foreign women. umbrella.

Finally there is the language of “legacy” itself, which may mean that some Republicans have realized the advantages of leaving the Trump era behind. Andrew Giuliani to be Not alone In his use of the from there in response to Friday’s Dobbs news. “We have Trump to thank for this,” tweeted a commentator, Allie Beth Stuckey. “It is not that a single malicious tweet in the world can overshadow what is now the greatest presidential legacy in history.”

And while much feedback get news Dobbs is evidence of the politics life, others had something of a tone of reminiscence or even offering a grateful goodbye: “Thank you, Donald Trump. You had the courage to run in 2016. You received 3 SCOTUS picks. Roe is gone,” speak Ned Ryun, executive director of far-right activist group American Majority. A Washington Post columnist, Marc Thiessen, while praising Mr Trump as “our greatest dear president”, is worth four years of turmoil and “unspecified behavior after the 2020 election”. “, totally hope that he “doesn’t come back in 2024.”

Have. But legacy is the stuff of funerals, retirement parties, and lifetime achievement awards. This is not the language one uses for a politician whose glory lies ahead of him. It envisions him as a leader whose work is cherished – yet remembered, unpredictable.

Bonnie Kristian (@bonniekristian) is the author of the forthcoming book “Unreliable: The Crisis of Knowledge Breaks Our Brains, Contaminates Our Politics, and Damages the Christian Community. “She is a columnist at Christian Today and a fellow at Defense Priorities, a foreign policy think tank.

The Times is committed to publishing variety of letters for the editor. We’d love to know what you think of this or any of our articles. Here are some advice. And here is our email: [email protected].

Follow the New York Times Opinion section on Facebook, Twitter (@NYTopinion) and Instagram.