Investors start to lower prices far fetch – pushed its stock down more than 35 percent in more than Cautionary guidance issued at Capital Market Day on Thursday — but many analysts remain fans even as the stock has a rough road ahead.
far fetch shares rebounded 5.2% to $5.80 in midday trading on Friday as analysts acknowledged the company was having a hard time trying to give Wall Street guidance on the upside. future growth.
More from WWD
“Management is in a ‘catch-22’ situation,” said Ike Boruchow, analyst at Wells Fargo. “If they had planned to trade with stronger numbers, investors could have averted the risk of guidance. Instead, they seem to have been guiding very realistic/cautious numbers — and the market is punching holes due to their inability to grow.”
On its first Capital Markets Day since going public in 2018 — several lifetimes ago with COVID-19 and the pace at which both fashion and technology are changing — Farfetch aims to reach a total merchandise volume of 10 billion dollars by 2025 with an adjusted profit margin of 10 percent before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization.
But the margins in the marketplace business, where Farfetch started, are set at around 5%, well below the 20% margins seen in the platform services business and the brand unit, which includes ivory white business, palm angel and others.
It is clear that some investors are looking for more from both the marketplace and the underlying services than relying too much on a branded business.
“Taking a step back, we see this as a way of management to ‘rip off support’ and reset growth expectations, and come up with a plan that leads to decent growth/profit aspirations,” said Boruchow. attractive,” said Boruchow. “Overall, we are still very bullish on the story, but admitting that the bulls will need a long time… The stock is simply in a bad position and any real change is in sight. Everything takes at least 12 months.”
Ashley Helgans, an analyst at Jefferies, said the big stock drop was “to a large extent due to a misunderstanding” and the guidance for 2025 could be seen as “very cautious”.
“Conservative assumptions include that the macro situation is still difficult and there are no new moves. [Farfetch Platform Services] Helgans noted that agreements were signed, albeit with a robust system. “With that said, we still believe in the long-term view, but the road seems relatively long at this point and the key drivers have yet to unfold, leaving sentiment always challenged.”
Farfetch is still navigating a consumer market with many unknowns.
“The big picture, the market and investors are now hard to see clearly in the next six months let alone three years, especially for a business that is several years old,” said Lauren Schenk at Morgan Stanley. missed financial results this year. As a result, we think the stock is likely to remain below a fair fundamental valuation until there is evidence Farfetch can deliver on its ’23 target, at which point the market may begin to recognize stocks for some of Farfetch’s ’25.”
Even giving conservative guidance, Schenk said the total valuation of Farfetch’s parts is at least $14 a share.
“We struggle to see further downsides from here and therefore remain overweight,” says Schenk.
